Wednesday, 29th December 2004

ah yes. the media.

Ah yes, that's why people are generally wary about talking to the media: to (poorly) quote The Hitch-Hiker's Guide to the Galaxy, "much of what they write is apocryphal, if not wildly inaccurate".

Let's count the dodginesses in the newspaper report from the Herald yesterday:

1. 'Tania had the white stuff'? Apart from being a dodgey pun, it sounds like I am doing cocaine or something.

2. I didn't have a "very white festive season" at all. The ground was made of brown rocks and dirt on Christmas day, as usual - Davis is located on one of the largest ice-free areas of the Antarctic landmass. Because only 3 or 4% of the continent is not permanently covered in ice, the fact it is not white here makes it very interesting indeed. However, saying "Tania can honestly say she had a dusty Christmas in a station that looks like a mining outpost" does not live up to the stereotypical expectations of Antarctica.

3. Eighty-four is the total Davis population. There were less people here at Christmas due to several parties working out in the field, staying at other bases or camping out overnight. But this is just a small carelessness compared to the mistakes coming up.

4. There is no "team that services and maintains magnetometers". It makes us sound like an atmospheric-sciences version of Lube Mobile or something: We're on call for all your magnetometry needs! We deliver to all seven continents!

5. Davis is not Australia's most southerly outpost. It is the most southerly permanently-manned Australian station, but we have equipment and field camps further inland.

6. IT IS NOT the "small changes in the earth's magnetic field" that cause all the destruction listed in the article. It takes a huge solar mass ejection of particles that slam into the earth's magnetic field to wreak that sort of havoc. This is a classic example of a reporter making something up, because he doesn't understand what he's talking about and he figures most of his reading population won't either.

7. Lastly (and most nitpickingly) we didn't eat outside, just retired there after dinner to drink champagne and stuff. Just another misquote that pales into insignificance with respect to the science reporting. However he had a run of mistake-free paragraphs at the end of the story so I suppose he had to sneak one in at the end to balance it up a bit.

Oh yes, there's also a point 8: Lloyd in the photo is not the helicopter pilot! He and I are sitting in the back seat of the chopper. I think the journo saw the headset and made the rest up. If you take a moment to look you will see I am wearing a headset as well. If you take another moment, think about where the camera would have to be, if it was taking a photo of the pilot and front-seat passenger. The camera man would have to be hovering about two metres infront of the windscreen. Not to disparage cameramen (or Damon who actually did take the photo) but I assume that it's not something they'd do voluntarily. Well, if they're all on cocaine in Antarctica, maybe they do some pretty crazy things down there.


Thanks very much to Simon and Marty for getting the website back up after recent crash; to Daniel for the mirror site; to Chris for the code to fix compatability problems (I will get around to implementing it soon!); to hostingshop for being cool with bandwidth issues; to all the visitors from home and via slashdot.


davis webcam
australian antarctic division

slush front page


posts

dreaming of a white icemass 2
final photos pt III
final photos pt II
final photos pt I
davis to hobart
the last days
caution: disgusting photos
jolly of the century
ode to 24-hour sunlight
donga tour
in the SHIRE
antarctic weblogs
ocean-bottom freakshow
farewell vasily
old book, nerdy joke
lots of stuff
seals, titan & monopoles
mwah ha ha HAR!
life in the freezer
dave & elly
zhong shan pt II
zhong shan pt I
new year
return of nice
ah yes. the media.
journos
christmas day
operation: dig to china
smuggling food to russia
ouch ouch ouch ouch
the week in pictures pt II
the week in pictures pt I
arrival!
agony: too much fun
Antarctic Voyage ABC
first berg, first snow
ocean in all directions
seasickness
the departure ...kind of
field training, auroras & tea
the pre-trip indices
Charlestown Square
a changed person
wall-of-death quad riding
surviving the nightmare
Pain Mesa, Mount Blood
the space physics blurb
new camera. woo!
alcohol rations
33ēC @ 33ēS
quotes on antarctica
nerdling issue 11
in need of lindt
the sanity test: revealed
use of interrobangs
medical check-up
rich snowbelt-saga cult
digesting the narods
the frontier furphy
the icy orrery
here be leeches
deep musings
interruption in transmission
the psych test
appendicitis and nazi sharks
eskimos schmeskimos
dreaming of a white icemass
here comes the science
going clubbing
survival handbook
strange behaviour
one two. one two.

get in touch

nerdling.zine@gmail.com
or sign the guestbook